Java Generics - cannot be applied to given type

Question

I have some code similar to this:

public class Main {

    private static abstract class Bar {}

    private static class SubBar extends Bar {}

    private static abstract class Baz<T extends Bar> {

        private T t;

        public void setT(T t) {
            this.t = t;
        }

    }

    private static class SubBaz extends Baz<SubBar> {}


    private void foo(Baz<? extends Bar> baz, Bar bar) {
        baz.setT(bar);
    }
 }

That results in error:

error: method setT in class Baz<T> cannot be applied to given types;
required: CAP#1
found: Bar
reason: actual argument Bar cannot be converted to CAP#1 by method invocation conversion
where T is a type-variable:
T extends Bar declared in class Baz
where CAP#1 is a fresh type-variable:
CAP#1 extends Bar from capture of ? extends Bar

I don't understand why. The method setT should accept something that extends Bar and I am passing something of class Bar.

Answer 1

The method setT should accept something that extends Bar and I am passing something of class Bar.

That's exactly the problem: <? extends Bar> means "Some unknown type that is Bar or a subclass of it". Since you don't know which type it is, it's actually impossible to call setT() in that context, except with a null parameter.

This will work as expected:

private void foo(Baz<Bar> baz, Bar bar) {
    baz.setT(bar);
}

There are, I am sure, hundreds of variations of this questions on Stackoverflow. It seems almost every programmer at first misunderstands what the ? wildcard is for and uses it wrongly.

Its utility is in the situation where your Bar class has a public T getT() method. A variable of type Baz<? extends Bar> could hold objects of both Baz<Bar> and Baz<SubBar>, and you could call getT() on it to get something that is a Bar (or some subclass) and can be used like that.