Doing a run-around of existing application to make database changes, good idea?

Question

We have an existing "legacy" app written in C++/powerbuilder running on Unix with it's own Sybase databases. For complex organizational(existing apps have to go through lot of red-tape to be modified) and code reasons(no re-factoring has been done in yrs so the code is spaghetti), so it's difficult to get modifications done to this application. Hence I am considering writing a new modern, maybe grails, based web app to do some "admin" type things directly into the database. For example to add users, or to add "constraint rows".

What does the software community think of this approach of doing a run-around of the existing app like this? Good idea? Tips and hints?

Answer 1

There is always a debate between a single monolithic app and several more focused apps. I don't think it's necessarily a bad idea to separate things - you make things more modular, reduce dependecies, etc.. The thing to avoid is duplication of functionality. If you split off an adminstration app separately, make sure to remove that functionality from the old app, or else you will have an unmaintained set of adminstration tools that will likely come back to haunt you.